Engagement
Going into this post I looked up engagement in the dictionary and thesaurus on my Mac, and to me the following thesaurus entry precisely captures how I treat this word in a workplace context:
PARTICIPATION, participating, taking part, sharing, partaking, involvement, association.
Behind all of these words is the notion of partnership: taking a share of the risk upon yourself. Risk can be anything you put into something, whether time, money, or any other resource you control, but it can also mean reputation, which is not fully under your control. I touched on this briefly in It’s about the business, not the tech, and now I’m paying my debt and diving into the third and final theme of the director’s role. Some might take engagement to mean the same as relationship, but to me (and the thesaurus 🤓) they’re not. Engagement is a structure in which two or more sides share risk, while relationship is how those sides treat and communicate with each other. In other words, engagement is the “what” and relationship is the “how”.
Getting people to share risk with you is ultimately a question of motivation, and there are two ways to get people to act:
- If they report to you in the hierarchy, you tell them what to do. Motivation by authority.
- You make them want to do the thing you wish to be done. Motivation by will.
As a director, much of the work that matters most involves people who don’t report to you: your fellow directors, their teams, and partners across the business. With them, the first option simply doesn’t exist. You can’t order a peer to put their people, their time or their reputation on the line for your goals. Motivation by will is the only tool you have, and that’s why engagement is central to the director’s role.
There are times when pulling the lever of authority is the right call, for example during an emergency, when there needs to be clear direction and a clear decision. For a leader it’s also by far the least effortful, least time-consuming option. You tell someone to do something, and if they resist, you tell them they have to because you’re the boss. That’s an extreme example, of course. Usually the harshness comes through in the tone rather than in those exact words. The thing is, people don’t do well in organizations where things are mostly done by authority. It demoralizes people and sours the atmosphere, fast. In the medium to long term this shows up as increased churn, because in a free market people will eventually look for new opportunities.
The second option, motivation by will, has some real downsides for you as a leader. First, it takes far more time, effort and trust to build. Sometimes people will misunderstand what you’re after and need “corrections”, which means falling back on authority. It’s also not “one and done”: you have to keep investing in it as the makeup of your org changes through promotions, resignations and layoffs. At the very extreme, if you’re the one who moves to another org, you mostly start from scratch, and you can only hope your reputation precedes you and gives you a foundation of trust to build on. You can’t use this tool for immediate effect. You wield it slowly and softly, reminding yourself to be patient with people. But most of the time the investment pays off. It creates the right atmosphere and gives people the latitude to experiment and innovate.
Engagement sits squarely within motivation by will. It has nothing to do with authority. So how do you get other people engaged with your goals? Here are some key avenues, though this isn’t an exhaustive list:
- Show up. If you’re invited to something, invest your time in the other party, and not in a transactional way where you expect something in return. This has to be balanced with your other commitments, so sometimes you’ll apologize and explain why you can’t make it.
- Listen. What do people need? What’s holding them back? Ask questions in return to make sure you’re both on the same page.
- Invite participation. Ask people to take part, and give them room to contribute from their own experience and expertise.
- Accept risk. You’ll have to take risks, and sometimes you’ll lose. That’s part of being a leader.
- Be accountable. Not everything will go according to plan, and you need to own that.
None of this guarantees engagement. In a very adversarial organization it won’t get you far. And even in a less adversarial one, if your area is lower priority, decisions will tend to go other people’s way.
The most direct way to build engagement with your fellow directors is to take on some of their risk yourself. When you lend them your people or your time, you’re putting your own resources on the line for their success, which is engagement in its purest form. Here are some things you can do as a director, depending on how “rich” you are in resources and whether your current priorities allow it:
- Help with org building: interviewing for their open positions, helping with onboarding.
- If you can, move someone from your org to theirs, whether as a promotion or through internal mobility.
- Ask your key people to chip in on projects your colleagues lead that need advice or help.
In the end, remember that engagement is very dynamic. Some days it’s abundant, and other days you’ll feel like you’re in the middle of a desert. But it’s also a skill you can learn and get better at, and over the medium to long term it pays dividends.